Cheese Database

Cheddar vs Colby

Cheddar is a hard cheese. Colby is a semi-hard cheese.

Cheddar is also used for grating.

Colby can stand in for Cheddar. A milder, moister American cousin when you need a cheddar-like melt.

Cheddar, field guide plate
Cheddar, photographed

Cheddar

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
Natural rind
Country
United Kingdom
Place
Cheddar, Somerset

Cheddar is a pressed cow's-milk cheese from Somerset, in the west of England. The name comes from the village of Cheddar and from Cheddar Gorge, but most cheddar eaten today is made far from that village.

Substitutes for Cheddar

Colby, field guide plate
Colby, photographed

Colby

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United States
Place
Wisconsin

Colby is a washed-curd cow's-milk cheese first made in Colby, Wisconsin, in 1885. Joseph F. Steinwand, a local cheesemaker, devised it and named it for the town.

Substitutes for Colby