Cheese Database

Cheddar vs Pimento cheese

Cheddar is a hard cheese. Pimento cheese is a soft cheese.

Cheddar is the one for melting and grating. Pimento cheese is the one for spreading and grilling.

Cheddar, field guide plate
Cheddar, photographed

Cheddar

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
Natural rind
Country
United Kingdom
Place
Cheddar, Somerset

Cheddar is a pressed cow's-milk cheese from Somerset, in the west of England. The name comes from the village of Cheddar and from Cheddar Gorge, but most cheddar eaten today is made far from that village.

Substitutes for Cheddar

Pimento cheese, field guide plate
Pimento cheese, photographed

Pimento cheese

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Soft
Rind
No rind
Country
United States

Pimento cheese is a cheese spread from the United States. Cooks stir sharp or mild cheddar with mayonnaise and chopped pimento peppers until the mix is soft and spoonable. Some recipes add a little cream cheese, onion, or a pinch of cayenne, but the three core ingredients define the dish. It is a prepared food, not a wheel with a rind. Jars and tubs are common in grocery stores, and many households still mix a bowl at home.

Substitutes for Pimento cheese