Cheese Database

Colby vs Monterey Jack

These two match on milk, texture, type, and country.

Monterey Jack can stand in for Colby. Another mild American cow's-milk cheese that melts easily.

Colby, field guide plate
Colby, photographed

Colby

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United States
Place
Wisconsin

Colby is a washed-curd cow's-milk cheese first made in Colby, Wisconsin, in 1885. Joseph F. Steinwand, a local cheesemaker, devised it and named it for the town.

Substitutes for Colby

Monterey Jack, field guide plate
Monterey Jack, photographed

Monterey Jack

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United States
Place
California

Monterey Jack is a mild cow's-milk cheese from California. Young Jack is pale, flexible, and one of the reliable melting cheeses of American cooking.

Substitutes for Monterey Jack