What it is
The milk sources listed for this cheese include cow’s milk and goat’s milk. The milk is pasteurized before cheesemaking. The listed producer is Haystack Mountain Creamery.
Flavor and texture
Its texture is described as creamy, firm and open. The rind is waxed. The flavor profile includes buttery and creamy notes. The cheese is pale yellow in color.
Serving ideas
Try Buttercup with plain bread or crackers to judge its texture before building a larger plate. If the piece spreads easily, a small serving can work as a topping; if it holds its shape, cut it into manageable portions. Choose accompaniments after tasting the cheese itself.
Remove wax and any plastic coating before serving. These coverings protect the cheese and are not the edible paste. Keep the remaining piece wrapped according to its packaging so the exposed face does not dry out.
Buying and storage
The cited product is associated with Haystack Mountain Creamery. Check the maker and full product name when buying Buttercup, especially if the shop offers a similar style from another dairy. The description above should not be assumed to cover every cheese with a related name.
Follow the seller’s or package’s refrigeration and opening instructions. Take out the portion you plan to serve, use a clean utensil, and protect the remaining cut surface or container. Packaging, moisture, and maturity affect keeping quality, so one storage time should not be assumed for every product.