Cheese Database

Cathedral City Cheddar vs Pilgrims Choice

Cathedral City Cheddar is a hard cheese. Pilgrims Choice is a semi-hard cheese.

Both are used for melting, grating, and a board.

Pilgrims Choice can stand in for Cathedral City Cheddar. Pilgrims Choice is another British block cheddar, and a matching maturity level can replace this brand in cooking or on a board.

Cathedral City Cheddar, field guide plate
Cathedral City Cheddar, photographed

Cathedral City Cheddar

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United Kingdom

Cathedral City Cheddar is a brand of cheddar from the United Kingdom, made with cow's milk. It is sold as a firm block, usually without a rind, in a range of ages from mild to very mature. The paste is dense and smooth, and the color is often a warm yellow. It is meant for everyday cooking and for the table, not as a single farmhouse wheel. The name belongs to the brand, so flavor follows the pack you buy.

Substitutes for Cathedral City Cheddar

Pilgrims Choice, field guide plate
Pilgrims Choice, photographed

Pilgrims Choice

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United Kingdom

Pilgrims Choice is a brand of cheddar from the United Kingdom. It is made from cow's milk and sold as a pressed block for the table and the kitchen. Mature and extra mature styles are the common ones, and both have a firm, close texture with no rind. A milder block is creamy and smooth. A stronger block is sharper, drier, and more savory on the tongue.

Substitutes for Pilgrims Choice