Cheese Database

Davidstow Cheddar vs Pilgrims Choice

Davidstow Cheddar is a hard cheese. Pilgrims Choice is a semi-hard cheese.

Both are used for melting, grating, and a board.

Davidstow Cheddar, field guide plate
Davidstow Cheddar, photographed

Davidstow Cheddar

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United Kingdom

Davidstow Cheddar is a brand of cheddar from the United Kingdom. The cheese is made in Cornwall, and it is a cow's milk block in the familiar British style. Makers press it and mature it, then sell it without a cloth rind. The paste is firm and pale to deep gold, with the clean break of a cheddar that has had time to rest. Shoppers meet it as a wrapped block, not as a grey farmhouse wheel.

Substitutes for Davidstow Cheddar

Pilgrims Choice, field guide plate
Pilgrims Choice, photographed

Pilgrims Choice

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
No rind
Country
United Kingdom

Pilgrims Choice is a brand of cheddar from the United Kingdom. It is made from cow's milk and sold as a pressed block for the table and the kitchen. Mature and extra mature styles are the common ones, and both have a firm, close texture with no rind. A milder block is creamy and smooth. A stronger block is sharper, drier, and more savory on the tongue.

Substitutes for Pilgrims Choice