Cheese Database

Best cheese for a baked potato

Cheddar is the baked-potato cheese. It melts into the hot flesh. Gouda is the milder melt.

Melt into the flesh

A split potato is hot enough to melt a pressed cheese. The cheese should soften, not sit as dry flakes or a firm slab.

Salt

The potato is mild. A sharp cheddar or a little blue shows up. A hard grating cheese alone stays dry.

The cheeses

A poor fit

Questions

What cheese is best for a baked potato?
Cheddar. Colby and Gouda are milder melts. A little Gorgonzola is the sharper choice.
Can you melt Parmesan on a baked potato?
Parmigiano-Reggiano stays dry. Use cheddar for the melt, and grate a little Parmigiano on top if you want it.

Cheeses for meltingCompare two of these cheeses