What it is
Carlos Ríos Moreno and Andrés Piña Calle founded the company in 1996. The name comes from a nickname for the village’s inhabitants.
Payoyo covers a range of cheeses rather than a single recipe. The producer makes goat’s-milk cheeses, sheep’s-milk cheeses and blends of the two, including fresh, semicurado and curado versions. Consequently, milk, maturation and flavor must be attached to a particular variety rather than assumed from the brand name.
Goat’s-milk varieties
The semicurado goat’s cheese is made from whole milk using enzymatic coagulation and matures for at least 35 days. The producer describes a natural rind, creamy texture, nutty flavor and slight acidity. The curado version has a minimum maturation of 105 days and a more pronounced goat’s-milk flavor.
Additional curado goat’s cheeses receive coatings of Iberian pork fat, paprika or rosemary. These treatments belong to specified products; they are not features of every Payoyo cheese.
Blended and sheep’s-milk cheeses
The semicurado goat-and-sheep blend matures for at least 75 days. Its documented character includes slight acidity, a hazelnut note and a texture that melts readily in the mouth. The uncoated curado blend has a minimum maturation of 120 days, with a tender, creamy paste and a biscuit-like aroma.
The sheep’s-milk semicurado matures for at least 35 days and combines intense flavor with a smooth, creamy mouthfeel. The curado sheep’s cheese matures for at least 105 days and has a straw-yellow color. These are separate recipes with their own maturation schedules.
Tasting the range
As a serving suggestion, compare the uncoated semicurado goat’s, sheep’s and blended cheeses side by side. This makes the producer’s documented differences in acidity, nuttiness and mouthfeel easier to explore.
For a second comparison, taste an uncoated curado cheese beside its coated counterpart. Check the exact variety: several coatings explicitly contain pork fat, and their additional cellar maturation differs between products.