Pick three roles
A board needs contrast, not a pile of similar wheels. Choose one mild soft cheese, one firm pressed cheese, and one cheese with a strong rind or blue veins. The first is creamy. The second slices cleanly. The third is the one people remember.
Brie or a fresh goat cheese can fill the mild role. A young cheddar, Gouda, Gruyère, or Manchego can fill the firm role. Stilton, Roquefort, or a washed rind such as Taleggio can fill the strong role. Swap the names when you need to. Keep the three roles.
Three cheeses serve a small table of four to six people. Add a fourth or a fifth only when the group is large, or when cheese is the whole meal. Two cheeses of the same age and the same milk will taste like one cheese, twice.
How many people, how much cheese
When cheese is one part of a meal, buy about 30 grams of each cheese for each person. Three cheeses come to about 90 grams a person, which is about 3 ounces. When the board is the meal, buy closer to 100 grams a person.
A soft cheese is eaten in larger bites than a hard cheese, so the soft wedge disappears first. Buy a little more of the soft one if you know the table likes it. Buy less of a very salty blue, because a small piece is enough.
Count the people who will actually eat cheese. A table with children, or with a large main dish already planned, needs less. The portions guide goes further into weights for a board and for a cooked dish.
Take the cheese out of the cold
Cold mutes flavor. Fat tastes flat when it is refrigerator-cold, and a firm paste feels waxy. Set the cheeses out before you eat them. A soft cheese needs about 20 to 30 minutes. A hard wheel needs about 45 to 60 minutes.
Leave the cheese wrapped until the board is ready, so the cut faces do not dry. Unwrap it, then cut the first pieces. Do not leave cheese at room temperature for more than two hours in total. That time includes the wait before the meal. Put the rest back in the refrigerator.
A very hot room shortens the safe time. A picnic in the sun is not the place for a soft cheese to wait. Serve it, then chill what is left.
Cut so the last slice is fair
Cut a wedge of firm cheese along its length, from the point toward the rind. Each slice then has both paste and rind. If you cut the tip off first, the last person gets only rind.
Cut a round bloomy cheese like a cake, in thin triangles. Cut a log of goat cheese into rounds. Cut a blue wheel in wedges, and leave the veins running through each piece so the look of the cheese stays honest.
Do not slice the whole board in advance if it will sit. Cut a few pieces so people know where to start, and leave the rest whole. A cut face dries faster than a rind.
Give each cheese its own knife
A washed rind or a ripe blue will scent the mild cheeses if they share a knife or a closed box. Give the strong cheese its own knife. A soft cheese also wants its own knife, because a hard cheese knife tears a ripe paste.
A small fork or a butter knife is enough for a soft cheese. A short blade is enough for a firm wedge. You do not need a special set. You need one tool that stays with each cheese.
Keep the strong cheese a little apart on the board. Space stops the rind from touching the mild paste. It also tells people that this cheese is a different bite.
What to put beside the cheese
Bread, nuts, and something sharp are enough. A plain baguette or a water cracker lets the cheese lead. A cracker that is already salty or sweet competes with it. Walnuts, almonds, or hazelnuts add crunch.
A firm apple, a pear, or a few grapes give water and acid. Pickled onion, cornichons, or a spoon of chutney do the same job for a rich cheese. Honey is a classic partner for a salty blue. Use a little. Mustard suits a firm cheddar.
Skip a crowd of meats, dips, and sweets on the same board. Those foods are a different course. If you want them, put them on another plate so the cheese stays readable.
A simple order of eating
Eat from mild to strong. Start with the fresh or bloomy cheese, move to the firm cheese, and finish with the blue or the washed rind. A strong cheese first will make the mild one taste of nothing.
Tell people the names. A small card, or a word said once, is enough. Most people will not ask, and then they cannot buy the cheese again.
When the meal is over, wrap each cheese again and chill it. Do not leave the board out as a second service hours later. The storing guide covers how to wrap the cut face so the leftovers stay good.