Cheese Database

Ashdown Foresters vs Caerphilly

Ashdown Foresters is a hard cheese. Caerphilly is a semi-hard cheese.

Ashdown Foresters is the one for melting. Caerphilly is the one for salad.

Caerphilly can stand in for Ashdown Foresters. Caerphilly is a moist, mild cow's milk cheese from Britain that slices for a board and softens in a gentle cook.

Ashdown Foresters, field guide plate
Ashdown Foresters, photographed

Ashdown Foresters

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
Natural rind
Country
United Kingdom

Ashdown Foresters is a hard cow's milk cheese from England. The milk is pasteurised, and vegetarian rennet is the usual set. Makers drain the curd in baskets without a heavy press, so the paste stays moist and a little open. The rind is natural and golden, with a basket-weave pattern, and the interior is pale yellow. The name refers to Ashdown Forest in England, not to a single ancient farmhouse recipe.

Substitutes for Ashdown Foresters

Caerphilly, field guide plate
Caerphilly, photographed

Caerphilly

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
Natural rind
Country
United Kingdom

Caerphilly is a pressed cow's milk cheese from the United Kingdom, and it is the Welsh cheese people mean when they want a moist, crumbly slice. A young wheel is pale and mild, with a clean lemon-like tang rather than a long aged bite. The paste breaks into soft crumbs instead of forming long strands. Traditional wheels grow a thin natural rind, while many creamery blocks are sold younger and simpler. It is firm enough to slice, but it still eats like a fresh tasting cheese.

Substitutes for Caerphilly