Cheese Database

Caerphilly vs Wensleydale

These two match on milk, texture, type, and country.

Caerphilly can stand in for Wensleydale. Caerphilly is another young British cheese with a crumbly cut and a gentle lemon note, and it fills the same role when Wensleydale is missing.

Caerphilly, field guide plate
Caerphilly, photographed

Caerphilly

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
Natural rind
Country
United Kingdom

Caerphilly is a pressed cow's milk cheese from the United Kingdom, and it is the Welsh cheese people mean when they want a moist, crumbly slice. A young wheel is pale and mild, with a clean lemon-like tang rather than a long aged bite. The paste breaks into soft crumbs instead of forming long strands. Traditional wheels grow a thin natural rind, while many creamery blocks are sold younger and simpler. It is firm enough to slice, but it still eats like a fresh tasting cheese.

Substitutes for Caerphilly

Wensleydale, field guide plate
Wensleydale, photographed

Wensleydale

Facts

Milk
Cow
Texture
Semi-hard
Type
Pressed
Rind
Natural rind
Country
United Kingdom

Wensleydale is a young English cheese from the United Kingdom. It is made from cow's milk and pressed into wheels or blocks that stay moist and crumbly. The flavor is mild, with a fresh tang and a light honey note. Plain wheels are white and clean tasting. Fruit versions mix the same curd with cranberries or other dried fruit, and both styles remain the same cheese.

Substitutes for Wensleydale