What it is
Its square shape is part of its character: the producer explains that square moulds drain differently from round ones, producing a smoother paste. Fine blue threads run through a pale interior.
The cheese also has a documented connection to musician Alex James and cheese writer Juliet Harbutt. Retailer Campbells identifies it as the cheese formerly sold as Blue Monday, a name taken from the New Order song. Cheese Cuisine credits its development to James, Harbutt and the Stone family of Highland Fine Cheeses.
Milk and making
The dairy uses pasteurized milk collected from farms around Tain. Cultures acidify the milk before rennet sets it, and relatively large curd pieces help retain moisture. After draining and moulding, salt is rubbed onto the cheese’s surface.
The producer describes piercing after about five days, followed by roughly two weeks of internal mould development. The cheese is then wrapped in aluminium foil and held near 3°C for two months. Campbells’ ingredient listing identifies the blue culture as Penicillium roqueforti.
Texture and flavour
Harvey & Brockless describes Blue Murder as soft, creamy and mild, with a thin, sticky rind coloured grey-white. The producer classifies that rind as washed. These descriptions place as much emphasis on the supple paste as on the blue veining.
Cheese Cuisine describes a changing texture: younger cheese has a spicier character and a texture reminiscent of feta, while further maturation brings greater creaminess. Its tasting notes combine sweetness and salt with a chocolate-like finish. Campbells instead emphasizes a bold flavour, illustrating the range of descriptions attached to this cheese.
Serving and cooking
Cheese Cuisine recommends Blue Murder for venison pie, blue-cheese sauce and soufflé. Its suggested accompaniments include honey, walnuts and acidic fruit, intended to balance the salty flavour. These are retailer recommendations rather than established regional customs.
For a simple serving suggestion, present a small wedge with walnuts and tart apple so the cheese remains the main flavour. A sauce or savoury pie offers another documented way to use its creamy texture.