Where it sits in the refrigerator
Cheese prefers the warmer, less windy part of the refrigerator. A drawer or a box is better than the door. The door swings through warm air every time it opens, and the cheese dries. The coldest back corner can stiffen a soft cheese and mute it.
Aim for ordinary refrigerator cold, about 4°C (about 40°F). Do not store cheese in the freezer unless you mean to freeze it for cooking. The freezing guide covers which cheeses survive that, and how to pack them.
Keep the box closed. An open block next to onions, melon, or last night's leftovers will take on those smells. Cheese is fatty. Fat holds odor.
Wrap the cut face
Cheese dries from the cut face, not from the rind. That face is the part you must cover. Press the wrap against it so air does not sit in a pocket. Air is what makes the edge dark and hard.
Rewrap the cheese after every use. A loose flap of old wrap lets the face dry and lets other smells in. If the paper is damp or smells sour, use a fresh piece.
A whole uncut wheel or a cheese still in its original unopened pack can stay as it was sold. Once you cut it, or open the pack, the clock and the wrap both change.
Match the wrap to the cheese
Cheese paper is made for this. It lets a little moisture out and keeps dust off. Wax paper or parchment can do the same job. Put that wrapped piece in a loose bag or a box with a lid that is not snapped perfectly tight, so the cheese can breathe a little.
Tight plastic against a bloomy rind traps moisture and ammonia. The cheese then smells harsh and the rind turns wet. If plastic is all you have, wrap the cheese in paper first, then put the paper parcel in a bag. Do not press plastic onto a ripe Brie and forget it.
A fresh cheese belongs in a closed container. Ricotta, cottage cheese, and fresh mozzarella in liquid should stay in the tub or the brine they came in. If you packed fresh mozzarella yourself, cover it with a light brine or its own liquid so it does not dry into rubber.
A firm or hard cheese tolerates a closer wrap than Brie does. It still needs the cut face covered. A hard cheese left naked in the refrigerator will be edible after you trim the dry edge, but you will throw that edge away.
Do not mix the rinds
Blue mold and washed-rind bacteria spread. Store those cheeses away from a bloomy round and away from an uncovered block. A shared box is fine when each cheese is wrapped. A shared unwrapped plate in the refrigerator is how a mild cheese grows a blue spot.
Give a ripe washed rind a box of its own if the smell is already strong. That smell is normal for the cheese. It is not normal for the butter on the shelf below.
The rinds guide explains which coats are food and which are wax, cloth, or paper. Leave wax and cloth on while the cheese is stored. They are part of the protection, not a snack.
How long it keeps
A fresh cheese is a short-life food. Eat ricotta, fresh goat cheese, and mozzarella in liquid within a few days of opening, and honor the date on the pack. A bloomy cheese is at its best in a short window. Once it is cut, plan to finish it within about a week.
A firm cheese such as cheddar or Gouda often keeps for two to four weeks if the face stays covered and the cheese was fresh when you bought it. A hard grating cheese can keep for a month or more. These are kitchen ranges, not a promise. Trust your eyes and your nose, and the past-its-best guide.
Buy a wedge you will finish. A larger piece does not save money if half of it dries out. The portions guide is the place to match the weight to the table.
After it has been on the table
Bring out only what you will eat. Put the rest back while it is still cold. Cheese that has sat out for more than two hours should be thrown out, not saved for tomorrow. A very hot room shortens that time.
The two hours include the time the cheese spent coming to room temperature. A board that waited an hour before dinner has one hour of service left. Wrap what remains and chill it. Do not put warm cheese in a sealed box while it is still steaming. Let the surface cool, then close it, so you do not trap heat.
A dry edge on a firm cheese can be trimmed later. A soft cheese that smells of ammonia after a long afternoon is finished. Do not try to freeze a tired piece to rescue it.
At the shop and on the way home
Ask the counter to wrap a cut wedge so the face is covered. A hot car is a bad place for a soft cheese. Take it home and refrigerate it before you do other errands on a warm day.
Pre-cut cheese in a sealed pack is protected until you open it. After that, treat it like any cut wedge. If the pack is swollen, leaking, or past the date, do not buy it.
A cheese you will serve tonight can stay wrapped in the refrigerator until it is time to warm it. Do not leave it on the counter all afternoon just because dinner is later.