What it is
The producer uses raw, unpasteurized milk from its own grazing herd. Cheesemaking begins within twelve hours of milking, with the milk traveling only about fifty yards from the farm to the dairy.
The cheese is made as a round truckle and belongs to the clothbound cheddar tradition. Calendar Cheese’s account of the Neal’s Yard Dairy selection describes large wheels wrapped in cloth and rubbed with lard before maturation on the farm. This physical format is part of the identity of the cheese sold as Keen’s Cheddar.
From milk to truckle
Keen’s describes a hands-on process in which the cheesemaker decides how each stage proceeds. After molding, the cheese undergoes three days of pressing and hot-water bathing. Wheels are turned by hand during maturation and assessed at three, six and nine months.
The producer connects its pressing process with a crumbly texture. Its own account gives differing upper maturation periods in different passages, while Calendar Cheese describes aging for up to eighteen months. An individual piece therefore needs its own age information rather than an assumed fixed age for the whole range.
Flavor and texture
Specialist descriptions show why Keen’s deserves a profile of its own. Calendar Cheese describes a dense, smooth cheese with lively acidity at the finish and a horseradish-like flavor. Capella Cheese emphasizes richness and creaminess, with flavors ranging from savory and mustard-like to brighter, juicier notes.
These accounts describe overlapping but distinct impressions. Together they suggest a cheddar whose acidity and savory intensity can be as noticeable as its richness. The producer’s description of crumbliness and the merchants’ emphasis on density also show that a firm cheese can have several textural qualities at once.
Serving and cooking
Capella specifically suggests grating Keen’s Cheddar over pan-fried mushrooms on toast. That is a merchant’s serving recommendation, and a useful documented cooking application for this particular cheese.
As an additional serving suggestion, taste a small piece plain before using it in that dish. Doing so makes it easier to notice the mustard-like or horseradish-like notes described by the specialists and how they interact with the mushrooms.