What it is
Its ingredient list specifies pasteurised local Jersey cow’s milk, salt, cultures and enzymes. The maker’s catalog gives an ageing range of sixteen to twenty months.
This is a natural-rind Gouda with a mature flavour profile. Urban Stead compares its taste to salted caramel and butterscotch, followed by a persistent umami finish. Its Cave Box listing places it among the company’s hard cheeses and emphasises creamy nuttiness.
An urban creamery and rural milk supply
Urban Stead makes and sells cheese at its premises in Cincinnati’s East Walnut Hills/Evanston area. The setting is urban, but the milk supply comes from outside the city: the producer’s process account identifies Bohl’s Jerseys in Mowrystown, Ohio.
That account describes weekly milk collection by truck and handmade cheesemaking on site. Gouda is expressly included among the cheeses made through this process. The company also reports sending whey from cheesemaking to a local farmer for livestock feed.
Natural rind and maturation
Zingerman’s specialist account confirms that ‘Nati Gouda is left unwaxed. It quotes the makers explaining that a natural rind was a deliberate choice: they wanted its appearance to remain visible and considered the rind helpful to flavour development.
The same account describes a creamy cheese with tyrosine crystals at sixteen to twenty months. This adds a textural detail beyond the caramel comparisons in the catalog. The Cave Box uses a broader sixteen-to-eighteen-plus-month description, so the published ages should be read as ranges rather than one exact age.
Recognition and serving
Urban Stead records World Cheese Awards gold in 2024 and silver in 2025 specifically for ‘Nati Gouda. Its catalog also lists first place in Aged Gouda and third place Best in Show at the 2026 American Cheese Society competition.
Zingerman’s describes buttery, nutty and subtly sweet flavours, recommending the cheese alone, with bread and cultured butter, or with seasonal stone fruit. As a serving suggestion, compare a plain piece with a bite of peach or plum to explore its sweetness and savoury finish.