Cheese Database

Vermont cheddar

Vermont cheddar is a regional family of American cow’s milk cheddars, encompassing different makers, maturation periods, and finishes.

At a glance

What it is

Shelburne Farms explicitly describes its cheese as artisanal Vermont cheddar and has made it since 1980. Cabot’s range includes Vermont Sharp alongside stronger cheddar grades.

The regional name therefore accommodates substantial variation. Shelburne Farms uses raw milk from its own pasture-raised Brown Swiss herd, whereas Cabot documents pasteurization in its cheddar process. Those production choices belong to the individual dairies; neither establishes a universal rule for every Vermont cheddar.

Two documented production approaches

Shelburne Farms makes cheddar with milk, starter culture, rennet, and salt. After cutting and warming the curd, its cheesemakers drain the whey and form curd packs. They cut these into slabs, repeatedly turn and stack them, then mill and salt the curd before pressing it overnight into blocks.

Cabot’s published process follows pasteurization with culture and rennet addition, curd cutting, cooking, whey drainage, and salting. Its cheese is packed into vacuum-sealed blocks or round waxed forms and matured in a temperature-controlled warehouse. Packaging and maturation thus vary within the regional category.

Age and flavor

Cabot explains that aging time is the principal distinction between its Vermont Sharp, Extra Sharp, and Seriously Sharp products, while graders assess when each cheese is ready. Its Vermont Sharp is designed for consistent flavor; Seriously Sharp has greater batch variation.

Shelburne Farms’ 2021–22 catalog illustrates a different maker’s progression. Its six-month cheddar is supple and delicately flavored, the two-year cheese is savory and creamy, and the three-year reserve is crumbly with fruity notes. Its clothbound version has an earthy flavor and flaky texture.

Uses matched to the cheese

Shelburne Farms recommends its six-month cheddar for melting and describes apples and honey as accompaniments to its one-year cheese. For the clothbound version, the dairy suggests pickles, strong mustard, and English ale.

As a serving suggestion, compare a younger block cheddar with a longer-aged or clothbound example from the same maker. That comparison highlights changes in texture and flavor without assuming that similarly named sharpness grades taste identical across different Vermont dairies.

Sources

More from United States.

Guides