What it is
It combines matured organic cheddar with chilli paste, giving the cheese a distinctly hot character alongside the savoury richness of its base.
The seasoning is more elaborate than a scattering of dried pepper. Published ingredients include cider vinegar, garlic, dark brown sugar, bird’s-eye chillies and cayenne. These additions bring acidity, sweetness and aromatic heat into a cheese whose texture remains creamy.
Maturation and ingredients
Godminster’s tasting sheet states that the cheddar matures for up to twelve months before chillies are incorporated. It identifies pasteurised cow’s milk, Soil Association organic certification and suitability for vegetarians. The documented sequence matters: Devil’s Dance begins with matured cheddar rather than relying on chilli alone for its flavour.
Abel & Cole lists a formulation containing 97 percent organic cheddar and 3 percent organic chilli paste. The retailer attributes the hot-sauce recipe to Godminster founder Richard Hollingbery, describing a combination of British Daredevil chillies, cider vinegar and garlic.
Flavour, texture and appearance
The producer describes a sweet counterpoint to the chilli and garlic, with calcium lactate crystals adding small crunchy interruptions to the creamy paste. Chilli flakes remain visible, and the sauce gives the cut surface a mottled appearance.
Murray’s tasting description adds fruity and savoury notes to the cheddar itself and characterises the spice as substantial. Garlic and brown sugar contribute to the seasoning’s balance. Abel & Cole documents a black wax covering; this is an external wrapper to remove before eating.
Serving and cooking
Murray’s recommends slicing Devil’s Dance for sandwiches or using it to top a burger, as well as serving it with salami and honey. These uses put its chilli seasoning directly into the finished bite.
As a serving suggestion, try a small slice on plain bread first to judge the heat before adding chutney or other strong accompaniments. For a burger, a modest portion is a useful starting point: the cheese already supplies garlic, sweetness and pepper heat, so extra chilli sauce is optional.