A name and a style are different
Some cheese names are tied to a place and a method. Parmigiano-Reggiano, Roquefort, and Brie de Meaux are that kind of name. A cheese labeled only parmesan, blue cheese, or brie can be a related style from somewhere else. The rules and the taste are not the same.
Cheddar is usually a style, not one protected cheese. A few regional cheddars do have a protected name. Most cheddar in a shop is a method: a cow's milk cheese, often colored, aged for some number of months. The age and the maker tell you more than the word cheddar.
Buy the name you mean. If you want the protected cheese, look for the full name and the mark that comes with it. If you want a style for cooking, a clear label with milk, country, and age is enough.
What a protected name promises
A protected name means a group of makers agreed, and a state recorded, where the cheese is made and how. Parmigiano-Reggiano is cow's milk from a defined part of Italy, and it is aged at least 12 months. Roquefort is sheep's milk, blued in a defined way. Brie de Meaux is a raw cow's milk cheese from a defined area, not every soft white round.
In the European Union, feta is a protected cheese from Greece, made from sheep's milk or a mix of sheep's and goat's milk, and kept in brine. In the United States, feta is also a style name. A tub there can be cow's milk. Both can be good. They are not the same cheese. The label's country and milk line are how you tell.
A style named after a place can still be honest. A maker who says Gouda-style, or who names a country that is not the Netherlands, is telling you the truth. A maker who uses a protected name without the right is not. Prefer the label that shows its work.
The milk on the label
The animal should be named: cow, goat, sheep, water buffalo, or a mix. That one word changes the fat and the flavor. The choosing-milk guide walks through each animal. Do not skip the line because the cheese name sounds familiar.
A blend should list the milks. If it does not, ask. Mixed milk is traditional in some cheeses and a cost choice in others. You deserve to know which one you are holding.
Pasteurized or raw is a second milk fact. It describes the heat treatment, not the animal. Read both.
Raw milk and pasteurized milk
Raw-milk cheese is made from milk that was not pasteurized. Pasteurized cheese is made from milk that was heated to reduce bacteria. Neither word means the cheese is better. It tells you the milk treatment, and it changes who the cheese is for.
In the United States, cheese made from unpasteurized milk is sold after it has been aged at least 60 days. Other countries set other rules. A fresh raw-milk cheese that is legal in one place may not be sold in another. The label, not a guess, is the record.
People who are pregnant, very old, very young, or unwell are often told to avoid raw-milk cheeses and other raw-milk foods. Follow the advice you already have from a clinician. The label can tell you the words. It cannot choose the cheese for you.
Age, date, and weight
Age is flavor and texture. A cheddar aged two months and a cheddar aged two years share a name and not much else. Look for a number of months, or for words such as fresco, joven, viejo, or reserve. Then look at the cheese. A dry face supports a claim of long age. A soft wet face does not.
A date on the pack may be a best-before date, about quality, or a use-by date, about a food that spoils quickly. Treat a use-by date on a fresh cheese as a real stop. A best-before date on a hard wedge means the maker's promise of quality, not a switch that makes the cheese unsafe at midnight. The past-its-best guide helps after the date has passed.
Read the weight you will eat. A cheese in brine should show a drained weight. A waxed wheel includes wax you will throw away. Compare prices on the paste, not on the package.
The ingredient list
A short list is normal: milk, cultures, salt, and rennet. Rennet may be from an animal, from a microbe, or made by fermentation. A vegetarian needs the non-animal kind. The label does not always say which rennet it uses. When it matters, ask the shop or the maker.
Annatto is a color. It makes some cheddar and Red Leicester orange. It is not a flavor of age. Herbs, spices, smoke, leaves, and pepper are added tastes. They should be named. A long list of powders on a grated cheese is often there to keep shreds separate. The grating guide explains why that changes the melt.
Some European labels show a fat percentage that means fat in the dry matter, not fat in the bite you eat. The cheese still contains water, so the fat in a portion is lower than that number. If the label does not say which figure it is, do not treat it as the fat in the wedge.
Words that are not fixed rules
Farmhouse, artisan, traditional, and natural are not the same legal term in every country. Some places define them. Many do not. They can be true, and they can be decoration. Trust the milk, the place, the age, and a name you can look up.
Imported can mean the cheese was made in the place on the label, or only that an idea traveled. Look for a country of origin and a producer. A town, a creamery, and a lot number are better signs than a gold banner.
When the front of the pack and the back disagree, believe the back. The ingredient list and the protected name are the parts that have to be specific. The picture is allowed to be charming.