A strong smell is not always spoilage
Some cheeses are supposed to smell loud. A washed rind can smell of stock, earth, or a little ammonia when it is ripe. A blue smells sharp. A ripe bloomy cheese smells of mushrooms and cream. Learn the smell of the style before you throw it out.
Open the wrap and let the cheese breathe for a minute. Ammonia trapped in a closed box can fade. If the smell stays harsh, and the taste is bitter or chemical, the cheese is past the point where it is pleasant.
Trust a change from the cheese you bought. A mild cheddar that suddenly smells sour, yeasty, or like old socks has a problem. A Taleggio that smells farmyard may be exactly itself. When you are unsure, cut a small piece from the center and taste it. Do not taste a soft cheese that has grown a mold it did not come with.
Crystals are not mold
A hard cheese can grow small white crystals. In Parmigiano-Reggiano and aged Gouda they are often amino-acid crystals. They crunch. They are a sign of age, not of spoilage. In a long-aged cheddar, white spots can be calcium lactate crystals. They are also normal.
Crystals sit in the paste as glassy or powdery specks. Mold sits on a surface as fuzz, usually green, blue, white, or black, and it looks soft. If you can brush a colored fuzz off a cut face, treat it as mold. If the white bits are inside an otherwise clean hard cheese and they crunch, they are crystals.
Do not trim crystals out of a grating cheese. They are part of the bite people pay for. Do not try to eat fuzz because you hope it is a crystal.
When to trim a firm or hard cheese
A firm or hard cheese can grow a spot of mold on a cut face. Cut that spot away with a margin of about 2.5 centimeters, about an inch, around it and below it. Then use the rest. The paste of a hard cheese is dense enough that the mold has usually stayed near the surface.
Do not let the knife touch the mold and then the clean face. Wipe the knife, or wash it, before you cut the piece you will eat. Rewrap the clean face in fresh paper. The old wrap is carrying the mold.
A dry, dark, or cracked edge can be trimmed the same way, without the wide margin, because dryness is not mold. Taste the paste under it. If the cheese smells clean, keep it. The storing guide explains how to wrap the face so the next edge does not dry.
When to throw a soft or fresh cheese out
Throw out a fresh cheese or a soft cheese if it grows a mold it was not made with. Ricotta, cottage cheese, cream cheese, fresh goat cheese, and mozzarella do not get a trim. Their paste is wet. You cannot see how far the mold has traveled.
Throw a soft cheese out if the paste is slimy, or pink or yellow when it should be white. A bloated tub, a hiss of gas when you open it, or a broken seal is enough reason to bin it. Do not taste it to check.
A bloomy cheese is supposed to have a white coat. Extra mold of another color, or a wet black smear, is not that coat. Throw it out. A blue cheese is supposed to be blue inside. Fuzzy mold of a new color on the outside of a wet blue is a reason to throw it out rather than trim.
A bloomy or washed cheese that has gone too far
A ripe Brie or Camembert bulges gently and creams under the rind. A young one is chalky in the center. Chalk is not spoilage. It is age. Leave it a day or two at refrigerator temperature if you want it softer, still wrapped, and check it again.
A bloomy cheese that has collapsed into a bitter liquid, or that smells only of ammonia, is past eating. A rind that has slipped completely loose, with a sharp brown smell, is past eating. Bake a cheese that is a little too soft only if it still tastes good. Heat will not fix bitterness.
A washed rind with a little ammonia at the surface can still be excellent under the rind. Cut a slice and taste the paste. If the paste itself is sharp and empty, the cheese is finished. Do not serve a cheese that makes people lean back when the box opens, unless you already know that cheese and like it that way.
Dates, seals, and time on the table
The date on a fresh cheese is a real limit. Eat it by then, and sooner if it smells wrong. The date on a hard wedge is often about quality. A dry edge can be trimmed. A sour smell cannot. When the pack says use by, treat a fresh or soft cheese as finished on that date.
An unopened pack that is swollen has made gas. Do not open it to see. A pack that was warm in a car for hours is a poor risk for a fresh cheese. Refrigerate a firm cheese and use it soon, or throw it out if it was hot.
Cheese that has sat out for more than two hours should be thrown out. Do not put it back, and do not freeze it to save it. The freezing guide is for fresh, cold cheese you plan to cook later. It is not a rescue for a board that stayed up all night.
A practical way to decide
Look, smell, then taste only if the cheese is a firm style with a small surface problem. Crystals, a dry edge, and a normal washed-rind smell can stay. Fuzzy mold on a hard cheese is trimmed with a wide margin. Any unexpected mold on a soft or fresh cheese means the bin.
When you keep a trimmed cheese, wrap it again and eat it soon. When you throw a cheese out, wash the container it sat in. Mold moves on a wet shelf more easily than people expect.
If you cannot tell, throw it out. Cheese is not worth a guess when the signs disagree. Buy a smaller piece next time so the question comes up less often. The portions guide is built for that.