What it is
The protected cheese is made only in Derbyshire, Leicestershire, or Nottinghamshire. It is not made in the village of Stilton.
The paste is crumbly, and the flavor is savory rather than salty-sharp. There is also a white Stilton, without blue mold. Most people who say Stilton mean the blue.
History
The village of Stilton, in Cambridgeshire, was a coaching stop on the road north from London. Cheese from the Midlands was sold there to travelers, and the village name stuck to the cheese. The making stayed in the three counties that still hold the protection. The village that supplied the name is outside that zone, so it cannot make the protected cheese.
Blue Stilton became a Christmas and port cheese in Britain, a wheel brought out for a celebration rather than a daily cooking cheese. The modern rules have a feature that surprises people who know other great blues. Protected Stilton is made from pasteurized milk, not raw milk. White Stilton is a younger, milder cheese from the same world, without the blue veins. It is a different product.
How it is made
Pasteurized cow’s milk is coagulated, and the curd is drained, milled, salted, and placed in cylindrical molds. The cheese is not pressed in the way a hard cheese is. The surface is smoothed to help form the natural rind, and piercing later introduces air that supports development of blue veins.
Pasteurization is required for the protected blue. That single rule separates the method from Roquefort, which is raw sheep's milk ripened in caves. Stilton's character comes from the cow's milk, the crumbly make, and the ripening in the three counties. A raw-milk blue made elsewhere may be wonderful. It is not allowed to use this name.
Flavor and texture
Blue Stilton tastes savory, salty, and rich, with a crumbly paste and pockets of blue that are sharper than the cream around them. People often find it less harshly salty than Roquefort, and less sweet than Gorgonzola dolce. A good wheel has a cellar smell that is clean, sometimes a little like wet stone or mushrooms.
Blue Stilton can be both crumbly and creamy. The texture changes with maturity and producer, so it need not be uniformly dry. White Stilton is milder and lacks the characteristic blue flavor; added fruit changes it further.
In the kitchen
Put blue Stilton on a board, in thick pieces, with bread, celery, a firm pear, or walnuts. In Britain a glass of port is the classic partner. A small amount crumbled into a soup, such as a broccoli or celery soup, or stirred into warm butter, is the usual way to cook with it. Heat gently.
Do not expect it to melt into a glossy pizza cheese. It crumbles and softens. Do not use it where a recipe depends on the moisture of Gorgonzola dolce. Add a little cream if you need a sauce. For a salad, it works when you want savory crumbs rather than a salty sheep's-milk punch. White Stilton can be a mild table cheese. It will not do the work of the blue.
Around the world
Protected Stilton is an English cheese of those three Midland counties, sold across Britain and exported for holiday boards. The village of Stilton lives with the name and without the right to make the cheese. That odd split is part of the history, and it is still in force.
Outside Britain, Stilton is the blue people buy for a Christmas board more often than for a weeknight. Other countries make crumbly cow's-milk blues in its image. They need their own names. When a British recipe says Stilton, it means this pasteurized, crumbly, savory blue, not Roquefort and not a mild Danish blue.
Blue Stilton, White Stilton, and raw-milk relatives
Blue and White Stilton are separate products under the protected name. White Stilton has no blue veining and is often sold with added fruit. It will not provide the same flavor in a broccoli-and-Stilton soup or blue-cheese dressing. Read the complete product name rather than selecting by the familiar word alone.
Protected Stilton uses pasteurized cow’s milk and comes from the three specified Midland counties. A raw-milk blue such as Stichelton is a related cheese with its own identity. The milk treatment is part of what distinguishes the named products, not a universal ranking of their quality.
Making a sauce or soup
Crumble Blue Stilton finely before adding it to a warm soup or sauce. Start with less than you think you need and let it soften before tasting. Broccoli, celery, potatoes, and mushrooms offer different backgrounds for its savory flavor. Adjust the salt after the cheese has been incorporated.
For a dressing, mash a little cheese with your chosen creamy base and loosen it gradually. Leave some larger crumbles if you want texture. If replacing Gorgonzola dolce, allow for Stilton’s firmer body and add liquid as needed rather than assuming equal weights give an identical sauce.
Buying, serving, and keeping Stilton
At a cheese counter, ask for a piece suited to your serving date. A freshly cut wedge lets you see the balance of white paste and blue veining; a sealed portion offers its own clear opening instructions. Buy an amount that suits the board and any planned leftovers.
Serve it in small wedges with pear, walnuts, celery, or bread. Port is a familiar British pairing, but the cheese also works with simple nonalcoholic accompaniments such as fruit. Refrigerate the unserved part in its wrapping and protect the cut face from drying.

